| 1909 – Francis Finnigan | Thomas J. Conley – 1958 |
| 1911 – Charles F. Riegert | William J. Collins – 1960 |
| 1914 – August Gerdelman | Michael J. Minyon – 1962 |
| 1915 – Michael J. Manning | Thomas J. Madden – 1964 |
| 1916 – Patrick F. Courtney | Charles J. Burke – 1966 |
| 1918 – John A. Gilson | John K. Manning – 1968 |
| 1919 – William Rodgers | James G. Welsh – 1970 |
| 1920 – John J. Nagel | Joseph M. Cummings – 1972 |
| 1921 – John A. Helferty | James A. Gillece – 1974 |
| 1922 – James W. Kelley | Eugene E. Howard, Sr. – 1976 |
| 1924 – Charles V. Lynch | Albert J. Franks – 1978 |
| 1925 – Peter J. Lyons | Reginald F. Beckett – 1980 |
| 1926 – Robert H. Rabe | Eugene E. Howard, Jr. – 1981 |
| 1930 – James E. Bateson | Albert J. Jacquot, III – 1983 |
| 1932 – James P. Green | Robert W. Nickol – 1986 |
| 1933 – William P. Breen | George R. Schmidt – 1988 |
| 1936 – Thomas J. Scattergood, Sr. | Nicholas J. Fesi – 1990 |
| 1938 – Daniel W. Riley | James W. Ott – 1992 |
| 1940 – Edward F. McLarney | John J. Mazziotti, Jr. – 1993 |
| 1941 – Joseph A. Disher | Nicholas J. Fesi – 1994 |
| 1944 – Joseph E. Gilson | Al Johnson Jr. – 1995 |
| 1946 – Charles H. Barrett | William J. Carr – 1997 |
| 1948 – James J. Burns | George Ezekiel – 1998 |
| 1950 – Edward A. Rodig | Lennis F. Hughes – 2000 |
| 1952 – Joseph A. Schmidt | Mark Kiernan – 2002 |
| 1954 – Bernard F. McNulty | John A. Erwin III – 2004 |
| 1956 – James F. Shea |
Daniel V Farrell– 2006 |
|
|
|
| |
|
| | |